Is Online Private High School Right for Your Child? Comparing Homeschooling and Online High School Options

Sometimes figuring out the differences between online school and homeschooling can be a little tricky. Since Excel High School’s beginning, we have worked with families who wanted a fully online experience for their students as well as those who wanted to use our curriculum to supplement their students while homeschooling. In this blog post, we identify the key differences between online school and homeschool.

When it comes to providing a flexible and personalized education for your child, both homeschooling and online private high schools offer excellent alternatives to traditional schooling. If you’re considering these options, it’s important to understand their similarities, differences, and the unique benefits each brings to the table. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide which path might be the best fit for your child’s educational needs and future goals.

Similarities Between Homeschooling and Online Private High School

Both homeschooling and online private high schools are designed to provide students with the flexibility to learn in ways that fit their individual needs. Here are some key similarities:

  • Flexible Scheduling: Both options allow students to structure their study hours according to what works best for them. This is especially beneficial for students with unique schedules, such as athletes, performers, or those with part-time jobs.
  • Customized Learning Pace: In both settings, students can learn at their own pace, allowing for acceleration in subjects they excel in or extra time in areas where they need support.
  • Personalized Curriculum: Parents and students can have a say in the courses chosen or taken, providing a tailored learning experience that aligns with the student’s interests and career goals.
  • Family Involvement: Family plays a significant role in both homeschooling and online private schooling. Homeschooling, in particular, involves parents in daily instruction, while online private high schools often include parents in progress tracking and support.

Key Differences Between Homeschooling and Online Private High School

While these two education paths share several similarities, some crucial differences could impact your choice:

  • Curriculum and Structure: Homeschooling allows parents to select or create a curriculum, whereas online private schools provide a structured, accredited curriculum designed by professionals. Online schools like Excel High School follow academic standards, ensuring that students receive a quality education aligned with graduation requirements.
  • Accreditation and Diploma Recognition: Private online high schools are typically accredited, making their diplomas widely recognized by colleges, employers, and the military. Homeschooling accreditation varies by program and state, which may affect college applications and career opportunities if not properly accredited.
  • Instruction and Grading: Homeschooling usually requires parents to take on instructional and grading responsibilities, while online private high schools provide certified teachers, tutors, and grading systems to support students and alleviate this workload from parents.

Pros and Cons of Homeschooling

Homeschooling provides a unique level of control and personalization, but it also comes with its own set of challenges. Here’s a quick look at some pros and cons of homeschooling.

Pros

  1. Complete Flexibility: Homeschooling allows families to create schedules, choose curriculum, and set learning goals with total freedom, making it highly adaptable to each child’s needs.
  2. Customizable Learning Environment: Parents can tailor the learning environment to match their child’s preferred style, providing a comfortable and distraction-free space.
  3. Increased Family Involvement: Homeschooling fosters close family engagement in the child’s education, allowing parents to be directly involved in their learning progress.
  4. Aligned with Family Values: Homeschooling allows families to incorporate personal, cultural, or religious values into the curriculum if desired.

Cons

  1. High Parental Responsibility: Homeschooling places the full responsibility of teaching, planning, and record-keeping on parents, which can be time-intensive.
  2. Limited Access to Resources: Unlike private online schools, homeschooling families may lack easy access to specialized teachers or advanced coursework.
  3. Social Interaction Challenges: Socializing for homeschoolers depends on outside activities, co-ops, or organized groups, which may require additional effort.
  4. Accreditation and Documentation: Ensuring that the homeschool curriculum aligns with state standards and handling accreditation can be complicated and time-consuming for families.

Benefits of Moving to an Online Private High School

For families looking for flexibility but with added structure and resources, online private high schools offer a balanced alternative. Here’s how moving to an online private high school can benefit your child:

  1. Accredited Curriculum: Programs like Excel High School provide an accredited curriculum, ensuring students earn a diploma recognized by colleges and employers, easing their transition to post-secondary education or career pathways.
  2. Access to Qualified Instructors: Online private high schools provide access to certified teachers, tutors, and academic advisors, giving students professional support for challenging subjects and academic guidance.
  3. Comprehensive Support Services: Excel High School, for instance, includes support from Academic Success Coaches, SAT/ACT prep, and tutoring services, relieving parents from overseeing every aspect of their child’s academics.
  4. Flexible Scheduling with Accountability: Students enjoy the flexibility to set their own study times but still follow a structured program with deadlines and grading, creating a balance of freedom and responsibility that encourages growth.
  5. Social Opportunities and Extracurricular Activities: Many online private schools offer virtual clubs, group projects, and social events that provide students with social engagement—an aspect that can be challenging to coordinate in homeschooling.
  6. Independence and College Preparation: Online private high schools teach students valuable time management skills, building independence and responsibility, which are critical for success in college and beyond.

Why Choose Excel High School?

Excel High School combines the best aspects of flexible, student-driven learning with the structure, support, and accreditation families seek in an online school. Here’s what sets Excel apart:

  • Globally Accessible, 24/7 Online Access: Whether you’re across the country or on the move, Excel High School allows students to study wherever they have internet access.
  • Diverse Graduation Pathways: Excel offers multiple pathways, from standard to AP courses, allowing students to tailor their education to align with college or career goals.
  • Self-Paced Courses with Support: Students can work through the curriculum at their own pace, but with the security of knowing they have access to tutoring and coaching when needed.
  • Independence and Student Empowerment: Excel encourages students to take charge of their education while providing the resources needed to succeed, making it ideal for those who thrive in independent, flexible learning environments.

Both homeschooling and private online high schools offer unique benefits, and your choice depends on what environment best suits your child’s needs and goals. For families seeking a flexible, supported, and accredited educational experience, Excel High School provides the foundation students need to excel academically while building essential skills for a bright future.Considering a switch to online high school? Both homeschooling and online private high schools offer flexible, personalized learning environments, but there are key differences to consider. Homeschooling provides complete control over curriculum and schedule, while online private schools like Excel High School offer an accredited curriculum, qualified instructors, and comprehensive support services. This guide explores the pros and cons of homeschooling, the benefits of online private high school, and why Excel High School could be the right choice for students seeking a flexible yet structured learning path.

Recommended for You

Dive deeper with these related posts, handpicked to enhance your learning experience. From practical tips to inspiring stories, find more insights to guide you on your path.

Excel & Gale: Providing Opportunities Together

When it comes to earning your high school diploma, students have a lot of options today. When it comes to earning your diploma online, finding a credible program that will suit your needs is essential. The chance to earn your online accredited high school diploma has life changing implications for plenty of people around the country and the globe. Accredited diploma programs like those offered through Excel High School have opened the doors of success for anyone willing to walk through them. 

read more

Understanding The Digital Divide In Education

In a world where access to technology is a part of daily learning, students who don’t have access to the internet or the devices they need to access online lessons or assignments experience a digital gap dividing them from the equal opportunities afforded their peers. This gap has come to be known as “the digital divide.” Hardware such as mobile devices, televisions,. PCs, laptops, tablets, or access to the internet all either connect your student to the world of learning or separate them from it.

read more

Back To School Is Here – What Does That Mean For Online Students?

All the big stores are playing their back-to-school ads. Parents and students are heading to the stores to grab notebooks, uniforms, writing utensils, art supplies…all the things that get crammed into backpacks and lockers in preparation for the first day of school. Online students with Excel Middle and High Schools don’t have to worry so much about their exact back to school start dates, but if you’re trying to model your school year with those of the school district in your area, then it’s back to school for you, too!

read more

So Your Child Wants to Switch to an Online High School? Here’s What to Consider

Switching to online high school can offer flexibility, independence, and personalized learning—ideal for students with unique schedules or specific academic goals. But should you choose a public or private online school? This guide breaks down key differences, from course variety and flexibility to support options, and explores why students might consider online-only education. Discover what sets Excel High School apart with its globally accessible, tailored programs and dedicated support, making it a strong choice for students ready to thrive in an online learning environment.

read more

School Choice: What Is It & Why It Matters?

When you’re trying to find the best educational environment for your children, you start to realize how much the issue of school choice matters. And it matters regardless of why you’re looking into alternatives to public school: large class sizes, bullying, the lack of progress in your local school districts, or safety concerns. No matter what your reason is for wanting to seek more hopeful, innovative alternatives, it’s important to know what your state’s stance is on school choice and your tax dollars.

read more

Designed for students 18+, the Fast Track Diploma program provides a flexible, self-paced path to earning a high school diploma online, no matter how long they’ve been out of school.

Excel High School’s Standard High School program provides a well-rounded, flexible curriculum that meets graduation requirements while allowing students to learn at their own pace

Honors courses offer a more challenging curriculum with deeper content, critical thinking opportunities, and higher academic expectations for motivated students preparing for college

Catch up, get ahead, or add a few more courses to your record. Our online summer school is the perfect way to stay on track or enhance your transcript.

Our middle school program helps students in grades 6-8 build a strong foundation in core subjects while developing essential study skills for high school success.